Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christopher's Eclectic as Hell's avatar

I think saying 9/11 was a metaphysical event actually obscures its importance. It's an illustrative event and very useful tool as a comparison. When and right after it occurred, the media kept saying how 9/11 was the worst sneak attack since Pearl Harbor. A fair enough statement in of itself, but a more important question is what was the result of Pearl Harbor and how does it compare to the result of 9/11?

Pearl Harbor made us realize we faced an existential threat from a vicious expansionist regime with a massive military intent on conquest. How did we react? We mobilized our society and resources and utterly destroyed that regime in less than four years (and also helped do the same to an equally vile regime in Europe at the same time). What the US did in World War II was miraculous. And instead of salting the Japanese earth, we helped it establish a peaceful democracy that is now one of our staunchest allies. A pretty good result, eh?

9/11, on the other hand made us realize . . . what? That we faced an existential threat from a bunch of Muslim fanatics with box cutters hanging out with goats in Afghanistan? Hardly. Yes, 9/11 was horrible, the loss of innocent lives was tragic. But it was no existential threat; no one seriously believed the country was in danger of invasion. But the powers-that-be treated it like an existential threat and did everything in their power to convince us that it was. And what was the result? A government intelligence apparatus with Orwellian powers that seem to be directed mainly at its own citizens; a military and foreign policy establishment focused on lining its own pockets through defense and "foreign aid" contracts; and a bunch of endless wars that caused thousands of service members to be killed or crippled for life.

9/11 wasn't an existential threat, but through our own stupidity and arrogance we turned it into one.

Expand full comment
PK's avatar

I agree that in some sense 9/11 was the beginning of the end, and it is interesting to cast it in the light of 'God's judgment against a people'. I say this as someone who served in the (what would become) long, long wars following the attacks, who lost many a solid teammate in these wars, who met their widows and young children.

I remember in the days following 9/11 all of the talk was about "not letting the terrorists win". If you didn't do whatever thing was prescribed, often by GW Bush or the government more broadly, you were "letting the terrorists win." Mostly stopping the terrorists from winning comprised returning to pre-9/11 everyday life as quickly as possible. Go shopping, we were told. Only by doing this could we show they didn't rock us, bad. And it didn't take long--by the end of October of that year, if memory serves--for the enterprising amongst the government to seize upon the moment to pass the PATRIOT Act, and forever change our relationship to government, surveillance, and our Creator-endowed inalienable rights. Like many, I didn't know any better. I was a young man. I supported this stuff.

And now, more than 20 years later, I can't help but feel deep sadness in thinking that yes, indeed, the terrorists did win. In 2001, we said they'd win if they could knock us off our routine, cause us to falter, make our financial system collapse. It took a while, and, let's be frank, most of the damage was more due to an auto-immune response than anything the attacks directly did, but at the end of the day...I think they won. They caused the freest, greatest nation in the history of the earth to trade in its liberties for the security of an increasingly totalitarian state. The surveillance and forefeiture of rights at the center of the PATRIOT Act is directly linked to the social instability, lack of trust in institutions, lack of transparency, lack of accountability, and all the rest that has convinced us that free speech shouldn't be too free, censorship is ok, everything we do should be surveilled, and that coming things like CBDC will be logical extensions of this mindset. These may seem like tenuous connections, but look carefully. The connections are there.

The terrorists did not overrun us on 9/11, but they did seed a slow and steady infection that, decades later, has achieved exactly what they'd hoped: the crumbling of the Great Satan they set out to take down that clear September morning. I pray our nation will repent while there still might be time. But who will risk, who will stand, against this new tyranny and against this rebellion against reality itself?

Expand full comment
286 more comments...

No posts