Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eric Mader's avatar

What strikes me here is d’Anselme’s optimism. Not naive optimism, but one that shines in the midst of a hard-edged realism.

“Western civilization as we know it today is going to collapse—and that’s good news.” Etc.

From the evidence, France’s young Catholics seem to be downright … joyful. Which is an interesting conundrum. France has been the very Mecca of smug cynicism for most of modernity, and is now clearly choking on its own sophisticated libertine bile. Yet these French Catholics, unlike many of us in the Anglosphere, radiate confidence and joy.

Surely it’s due mainly to grace. But I’m thinking it also might be cultural. In a negative sense. It might be due to a lesson they’ve learned from their compatriots. Watching their elders scoff and smirk and pout postmodernly, they’ve realized: “No, that’s not the way.”

Compare this to us. Our national culture tends to be upbeat and sunny, often in dumb ways. Meanwhile many American Christians (I’ll speak for myself) lean cynical—not the same kind of cynical that defines the French, but still certainly not *joyful*. Pessimistic, say.

Probably we could learn something from the young French Catholics. “Yeah, it’s gonna unwind. It’ll be ugly. But praised be the Lord.”

Expand full comment
Man's Joyless Quest For Joy's avatar

The young man reiterated what I mentioned in a recent post - we have to endure suffering & no matter how much we push back before things will change. This could take generations. It is on God’s schedule - not our timeline. I would not be shocked if folks in USA just consented to a form of tyranny via technology. We are already seeing this in the AI debate. The irony is that the more security we seek the more fragile we become & the more compliant we become. Again this is a recipe for oppression. Caio from Amalfi.

Expand full comment
137 more comments...

No posts