99 Comments
User's avatar
JBS's avatar

Cheer up sir, no need to despair!

Expand full comment
James Therry's avatar

My wife (who is Italian) and I spend each summer on the beach just north of Rimini (just a few kilometers from San Marino). I might be able to talk her into running south for a few days

Expand full comment
Mere C's avatar

I had trouble getting in the right frame of mind for Divine Liturgy today, in a foreign (at least for now!) language. All I can make out is “Gospode pomiluj” plus a few other words here and there.

But when I go outside - everything is full of life, even in the sort of plain suburb I’m at now. Fresh fruits and vegetables that taste a thousand times better than in America are being sold, kids riding bicycles, everyone out walking. Even in the neighborhoods of the city that are full of really grim looking commie blocks, it’s always the same. This never fails to cheer me up. All I lack is the language - thankfully not nearly so difficult to pick up as Hungarian!

Expand full comment
Thomas F Davis's avatar

“So your idea of life in heaven is a reproduction of the life you have here in earth, in San Benedetto del Tronto?” I ask.

“Yes—but perfected!”

I firmly believe that in Heaven all good things of Earth will be remembered and all languages will be made intelligible. Let us just be patient.

Expand full comment
Laura M's avatar

Just a little while and a little while more, as the priest said at Mass on my son's 8th grade retreat.

Expand full comment
Martha Moyers's avatar

I also think we will be able to talk to animals & they will talk to us. Kinda like Narnia.

Expand full comment
Fieldofthewood's avatar

We probably won’t even have to talk. We’ll just know, and even the animals will know, because all in Heaven will be full of the knowledge of God.

Expand full comment
pondering in PA's avatar

I'm rereading (actually, re-listening) to the Narnia books now. Although they are clearly for children, they do lift my heart and mind.

Expand full comment
JasonT's avatar

In any case, it will be more wonderful than we can now think or imagine.

Expand full comment
Wanderer's avatar

For me personally, this is one of my favorite posts of yours ever. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Leonore McIntyre Meuchner's avatar

Oh Rod, be of good cheer, I will pray in church today for you to have a peaceful heart. Whenever I’m down I try to pray for humility because I know it’s me just feeling sorry for myself.

In the words of the great and wise golfer Harry Varden” never despair “!

Expand full comment
Scuds Lonigan's avatar

The Stylist

Expand full comment
John Kelleher's avatar

Rod your first paragraph indicates you have a problem that you need to have looked into. Do yourself a favor and have a consultation with someone you can trust. Don’t ignore this . Best wishes.

Expand full comment
Rod Dreher's avatar

No, I don't think just being down over a few things going on in one's life indicates a problem in need of professional assistance. This too shall pass. The PTSD thing back in January -- now that was a real problem that I needed help with, and I got it, and it was effective. Today's melancholy is a reasonable response to some events of the past few days.

Expand full comment
Richard's avatar

Which raises a interesting question. If your moment of melancholy wasn't pathological, but was an experience God wants us to have because, when used properly, it can actually deepen our faith, does Marco ever go through such times? Does he ever feel moments of despair? Does he ever get angry at God? C.S Lewis also lost his wife at a relatively young age, and he sure wasn't smiling at her funeral. He was furious and despondent about the whole thing. You can read all about it in A Grief Observed. Perhaps Marco has reached a higher spiritual level than Lewis did. But to be honest, it is easier for us ordinary mortals to identify with Lewis than with Marco, and I must say I have greater respect for Lewis for having battled his way through his dark night of the soul.

Expand full comment
Rob G's avatar

Unless you're the Holy Spirit this comment is out-of-line. How do YOU know what Marco's battles are/were?

Expand full comment
Richard's avatar

Well. If he does ever struggle with his faith, there's not a hint of it in the article. Perhaps it is Rod"s fault for turning him into some kind of plaster saint.

Expand full comment
Fieldofthewood's avatar

He doesn’t come off as a plaster saint to me. Struggling with this world’s imperfection and corruption and with life’s hard knocks, such as the death of a loved one, doesn’t have to mean a concurrent struggle with faith. Indeed, it can strengthen faith, as well as patience, and direct our attention more towards the marvelous good things that still remain in spite of evils. This is what Marco does, seems to me. I wish I could do this as consistently as he does. For now, we hunger to see good, to see the triumph of good in the land of the living; and if we hunger, we know there is bread — the Bread of Life, Jesus Christ. (Can’t remember for sure who said that. Might’ve been Malcom Muggeridge.)

Expand full comment
Richard's avatar

I never meant to imply that he isn't struggling heroically against the world, which he clearly is. I just meant that most of us ,if we had gone through what he has, would have found it more difficult to fight off spiritual discouragement , or even been a little more tempted to shake a fist at heaven, as C. S. Lewis did. If Rod had said just once that Marco had kicked his dog, I would actually have found him more inspiring, because more human.

Expand full comment
Alcuin's avatar

“...me in an isolated life, with just my books, my icons, and a dog”

Dante knew he’d bequeathed the world something special in his Divine Comedy, yet I imagine that was cold comfort as staggered the steepness of another man’s stair and the saltiness of his bread.

You, too, are an exiled writer sharing something special with the rest of the world, a rare combination of professional journalism and personal vulnerability, the world’s third most interesting neighbor leaning over the fence to share news and views almost daily. We here are grateful for that and can’t see you as a hermit. You enjoy people and their stories too much.

Expand full comment
Alcuin's avatar

"...the fantasy of selling all my things and going to live somewhere quiet, to withdraw from the world..."

I hope this is something you've taken to your spiritual advisor, Fr. N. and/or others. Given the good you're trying to fight for in preserving/reinvigorating Christianity and opposing totalitarians, it's a win for the bad guys if you retire from the field of battle. What spirit animates this 'fantasy'?

Expand full comment
Rod Dreher's avatar

Oh, it's just a spirit of weariness. You know, because we have talked privately in the past, the full story of my divorce and related brokenness -- the stuff I can't, or rather won't, share publicly. It's a heavy cross to carry on some days.

Expand full comment
Phillip's avatar

I think that if my wife passed I would head to a small, Rocky Mountain town with the Bible, a few classic books and a laptop with which I could occasionally check in on the world and listen to some music. Population 300 or less would be perfect.

Expand full comment
Brian's avatar

My brother bought a place in Italy in Polambaro, Chieti, Abruzo. It's not far from San Benedetto, and has mountainous views but none of the Adriatic, as it's a few hours southwest.

This was about 2 years back and the price was ridiculously low.....about 22,000 Euros. He said something like "I would be crazy not to.....I could have put half on my credit card."

Expand full comment
Alcuin's avatar

Wanna trade brothers?

Expand full comment
Brian's avatar

LOL!......He's the brother who probably made my mother a saint!.....so maybe we can make a deal!

Expand full comment
Dean Cooper's avatar

I love your friend Marco Sermarini. Give him a call and then tell him what you see looking out your window. And have a wonderful laugh seeing beauty and sharing it with him. Then ask him what he sees, what he hears, what he knows, and see if your heart is not filled to overflowing like his.

Expand full comment
JonF311's avatar

I've said before that Italy and the company of your friends in the Tipi Loschi would be good for you, if no where back in the US is possible.

Expand full comment
Angelo Bottone's avatar

Marco is a great inspiration. Everyone should visit their community, full of life and faith.

Expand full comment
Marco Sermarini's avatar

Angelino è un grande, lui sì, è pure abruzzese...

Expand full comment
Diana's avatar

Oh yes, sign me up :-)

Expand full comment
Christopher Terracino's avatar

I loved this post. Human and spiritual, a nice break from politics.

Expand full comment
Katja's avatar

Following politics too closely is a dangerous game.

Expand full comment
Rob G's avatar

I've mostly stopped following it period. See Rolf Dobelli's excellent little book "Stop Reading the News."

Expand full comment
Cyndi Kane's avatar

St. Federica, pray for our friend Rod today! Please ask the Lord for a gift from heaven that allows him to find joy today, and in a way that he knows that Heaven has intervened. Thank you ❤️.

Expand full comment
Katja's avatar

I'm hoping that the excursion out with a friend is helpful to your state of mind. As much as you enjoy Hungary - being in Europe, meeting people in various cities and having them come to Budapest - if you don't have some sort of everyday community, it's really, really hard. Even when I was in Germany, I could speak German, so I could do things like make it to a car parts store and figure out which spark plug wires I needed to get my car running again. (Stupid martens!) It's a huge difference! I hope you have people that you can call anytime, no matter what, but it seems like you need to have the stability of communities - both church and social - that are somewhat more permanent.

Expand full comment
Solitudinarian's avatar

They do like to chew on cables and hoses.

The martens, that is. I’m pretty sure the Germans don’t, although I can’t watch everyone.

Expand full comment
Katja's avatar

You never know wif ze Germans! ;)

Expand full comment
Rare Earth's avatar

Ironically, I just finished reading, Live Not By Lies, in the lobby of the Marriott in Prague. It was moving to read these accounts of heroic Catholics and Christians who lived behind the Iron curtain. On a foot tour of Prague last night, our guide made the point that one of the most beautiful Catholic Churches, St. Vitus Cathedral, which took 600 years to build, sits in the capital of the least religious country in Europe. He stated that the Czech Republic is 80% atheist. Interestingly, Slovakia is still quite religious and Catholic. While I was reading, another American, a woman from California, saw the title of the book and struck up a conversation with me. I gave her the background about the author.

Expand full comment
Rod Dreher's avatar

Oh, I forgot to remind you of the movie you're supposed to watch: "The Third Man," directed by Carol Reed.

Expand full comment
Rob G's avatar

Great, great movie -- showing tonight on the big screen here in Pittsburgh, as it happens. Not 100% sure I can go yet but am going to try.

Expand full comment
Fieldofthewood's avatar

One of my very top all-time favorites. Great movie.

Expand full comment